Saturday, December 3, 2011

27 Stagnant Years - Dow shall pay!


- Tears keep rolling

“It was the fateful days of 2nd – 3rd December when I cried incessantly. Ever since, I have lived the life of the dead. These two days, 27 years ago, brought with them the message of death. The time stood still and with that my breath. The first rays of the morning Sun fell on thousands of my dead sons and daughters. I could see them blurred through my tearful eyes and hear their deafening screams. Vultures eclipsed some of those rays that investigated the corpses. I wish that day never came. I wish I had much more than just a name. I wish I was capable of action.”

- deranged Bhopal

I think in attempting to personify Bhopal, I have not done even an iota of justice to the indignation that she shares along with her residents. However, can anyone? The purpose of this piece is not get into statistics (for we all know the officially we lost about 3000 lives, in reality there were more than 20000 or how many can never walk or talk or anything, plus the etceteras). I want to highlight the challenges that we face as a nation owing to the inexplicable soft stance of the government. I read the ticker of a news channel informing that Dow chemicals told Supreme Court that it won’t pay any more compensation ( Invigorated for their website mentions “Dow to receive 2012 Green cross for safety medal” – safety?). Now that’s some mettle! ([Offline] Much to the chagrin of the victims of the tragedy and of compassionate minds, Dow is the sponsor of the London Olympics. [/offline]) . Whereas our needle has not moved in getting Warren Andersen extradited (come on, don’t blame the government. Cut that old man some slack The Hindu life also believes that the age of renunciation should go peaceful. Hail Congress!).

What angers many like me is not that calamities happen, but that they can be avoided, with practically efforts no more than normal sanity checks. Hurts. The dead bodies piled exponentially in matter of hours that day – intelligent humans and not so wise animals alike.Add to it , the dismal past we have for truthful honest professionals. Rajkumar Keswani , an efficient journalist had foreseen this catastrophe and warned the government time and again. An excerpt from one of his interviews I paste below:

“I started working on this story in 1981. That was the time when my friend Mohammad Asharaf was working in Union Carbide India Limited. He died due to exposure to phosgene gas. I had an idea that some hazardous chemicals are being used in the Bhopal factory. I reported on his death and then worked for nine months on knowing about the factory. I reported my first story in September 1982. In October that year I ran a series and wrote weekly reports against Union Carbide and the possibility of risk to human lives due to the chemicals in the plant. People treated me like a crazy man. They used to tell me, 'Arre aisa kabhi hota hai kya? Aisa kabhi hua hai kya is duniya mein?' (Do things like this happen? Have such things happened anywhere in the world?)”

Source: http://news.rediff.com/interview/2010/jun/11/interview-man-who-warned-of-the-bhopal-gas-leak.htm

He posted his last article in October of 1984 warning the stubborn government. Needless to say, we had other things to look at.

However, we can’t repair the past. What are we doing now? We have thousands of people protesting for what should be their right. They have not received adequate compensation. Octogenarians in the street, suggests how much we respect our elderlies. (age of sanyasa/ renunciation – peaceful at that? Shameful). The lack of cooperation from US raises some doubts. Whilst , in the Deepwater Horizon Oil Spill, BP was given stern warning from the US government and it had to set aside multi-billion dollar fund to cover the cost of current and future losses (3 people died and It almost degenerated into a political war between the US and the UK), in case of India there we thousands who perished, but for our lack of conviction and loss of respect for each other, we are still no where. May be we can do some good by respecting people (beyond the days of voting).

Hope there is some divine intervention that makes the government realize the pain of its masters (the masses). Pro- activity can help save the day. We do not lack funds, just a dearth of empathy. I refuse to believe that while they can flaunt 3 crore rupees (per MP) in Cash-for-vote scam in a display shaming parliamentary democracy , they can’t take care of those who need them dearly ( to make a glaring contrast you can add the money involved in 2G , CWG etc etc scams). Classic case of Policy Paralysis. Whatever be the outcome of the court hearings, the government should help the victims and the family with their funds (may be scale down on their scams for funds!). I think the Kamal Naths, the Sharad Pawars can come forward and donate some sum out of their paltry accruals as politicians ( As citizens , we should too) to help the needy. A simple gesture to come in support would at least help bring a smile on the faces of those who have forgotten the meaning of good healthy life.

From

- 'Lucky'- not-to-be born in Bhopal

9 comments:

Dhruv Jetli said...

An honest attempt to highlight not just the plight of the tragedy victims, but a phenomenon which is starting to affect us all. It's more a case of dead empathy like you very well put it. People (and I'm not just talking of the government here but the common man) have started believing in the 'chalta hai' mantra that has been ingrained into us by the 'powers that be'. Be it any scam, terrorist attack (26/11) or any other calamity, what are we expected to do? Get up the next morning, rush off to work and forget the rest. That's what's come to be expected of us and somewhere many of us have started doing just that. Occasional stirs like that in the case of Jessica Lall do act like eye openers, but the government still expects us to 'adjust' with such things and live peaceful lives. Giving monetary or emotional support is something very much within our jurisdiction and it would, if nothing else, count as an act of humanity. But seeing the apathy of people in general and not just the government, I don't think an incident like 'A Wednesday' (a stirring movie with Naseeruddin Shah in the lead) is very far off.

Kritika R said...

It is not just the government that continues to show apathy towards the victims of the Bhopal tragedy. The masses of today are greatly, if not equally, ignorant of the damages it caused and the ordeal faced by the people who continue to pay for the damages.
What we lack is not money or the brains for using it. What we lack is the absolute desire to help people get back on their feet. The "atleast-it-didn't-happen-to-me" thinking keeps our mind blocked from realising that such accidents CAN HAPPEN AGAIN.
We crib about having to go through security checks at airport, we crib about the "long process" of verification at hotels. We forget that 9/11 can be repeated and that Taj could happen again. If its easy to let go of these potentially recurring events, it's fairly convinient for the people and the people's government to ingore those who have already suffered from the gas leak.
Handful of voices won't bring about a change. Even an Anna Hazare alone can't make a difference. Dow sponsoring an entire Olympic season while claiming it can't provide more restitution should be enough for the government and more importantly the people to come forward and take a stand or what it can and will not tolerate.
The government is not what makes the "people". People make up the government. If people remain ignorant and unwise about what has happened and what they DON'T want happening again, so will the government.

Rahul said...

@ Dhruv - You could not resist the Bollywood buzz in you, could you? The analogies you draw make perfect sense. Thankfully I have seen "A Wednesday" so that people do not ostracize me for not watching Hindi (for some reason they call it Bollywood) movies.

Totally agree. We are so helpless when these incidents occur. Utmost we can do is to show it on the news channels with good background score of have the Ram Gopal Vermas to visit the sites to make a movie!

Rahul said...

Kritika - thanks for the mini blog. High time you started with the full fledged one. I see shades of insights from the 'CA world' :)

Totally agree with what you have raised. The "atleast-it-didn't-happen-to-me" is such a relevant point you make - a syndrome that grips all of us. I wish we learn to value lives more than what we do at the present. An America would go great lengths to rescue her citizens or bring to book the culprits of her laws, we are so soft that we don't even intend to do either of these(It's not a question of being an advanced country, it is about conviction and conscience more).

SomyaSaxena said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
SomyaSaxena said...

The Indian Olympic Association (IOA) will not boycott the 2012 London Olympics, despite Dow Chemicals' association with the event. Due you think its fine??

SomyaSaxena said...

one more question rahul... why Ram Gopal Varma?

bharath said...

Agree with you that government has not done enough to compensate for its mistakes . but we must realise that India of 1980s was a poor nation which was on verge of bankruptcy. In such a scenario, there was very little that indian government could do.

and coming to point of US vs indian reaction to various incidents be it disasters or terror attacks..india is a high mortality society unlike US. hence death is part of regular indian life. Therefore an indian government faces far less pressure to act than US government . So ultimately we have to blame the psyche of our society for the apathy shown towards the bhopal gas victims

Rahul said...

@ Somya

I think boycotting the Olympics is a timid response, for we have no grudges against the institution as such. However, sentiments wise, yes. We should be stringent and relentless in our efforts to ensure that DOW drops the sponsorship. We have already made it drop its logo from the London Olympics.

as for Ram Gopal "Verma", he visited the 26/11 terror sites within days of the attack with the then CM of Maharastra Vilas Rao and his son Ritest Deshmukh for his movie!